6 Instances Consolidating Debt Really Hurts Your Credit score

Because the “One Massive Stunning Invoice” Act and shifting rates of interest reshape the monetary panorama, many debtors are dashing to simplify their lives. Debt consolidation—the method of taking out one new mortgage to repay a number of high-interest money owed—is the go-to technique. When executed accurately, it might result in a major credit score increase. Nevertheless, consolidating debt isn’t a “risk-free” maneuver. For those who don’t perceive the mechanics of credit score scoring fashions like FICO 8 or VantageScore 4.0, you may discover that your makes an attempt to “repair” your funds really set off a pointy drop in your rating. Listed here are the 6 instances consolidating debt hurts your credit score.

1. Closing Your Oldest Accounts After Payoff

The commonest mistake owners and college students make after a profitable consolidation is straight away closing the outdated, paid-off bank cards. Whereas it feels satisfying to “lower the ties,” this transfer will be devastating to your rating. Size of credit score historical past accounts for 15% of your FICO rating. Based on TransUnion, closing a 10-year-old account in favor of a brand-new mortgage can slash your “common age of accounts” in a single day. Except the cardboard carries a excessive annual payment, it’s nearly at all times higher to maintain it open with a zero steadiness to anchor your credit score historical past.

2. Triggering A number of “Onerous Inquiries” in a Quick Window

Each time you apply for a consolidation mortgage or a 0% APR steadiness switch card, the lender performs a “onerous pull” in your credit score report. A single inquiry may solely drop your rating by 5 factors, however should you “store round” throughout a number of months, these factors add up. NerdWallet notes that whereas scoring fashions group inquiries for mortgages or auto loans, they’re typically much less lenient with private loans. For those who apply for 4 completely different consolidation merchandise in 2026 with out utilizing “pre-qualification” instruments, you may see a 20-point drop earlier than you even signal a contract.

3. Spiking Your Utilization on a Single Steadiness Switch Card

For those who use a steadiness switch bank card to consolidate, you may inadvertently harm your “per-card utilization” ratio. Even when your complete credit score utilization goes down, having one card that’s 90% “maxed out” can sign excessive danger to lenders. Experian warns that top utilization on a single revolving account is a significant purple flag in trendy scoring fashions. In case your new “luxurious” consolidation card has a $5,000 restrict and also you switch $4,800 onto it, your rating might keep depressed till that particular steadiness is paid down considerably.

4. The “New Account” Penalty

Opening any new line of credit score—whether or not it’s a private mortgage or a house fairness line—briefly marks you as the next danger. This is named “New Credit score” and accounts for 10% of your rating. For the primary 6 to 12 months, the presence of a brand-new, $0-payment-history mortgage can act as a “drag” in your rating. Based on LendingTree, it is a momentary dip, however in case you are planning to use for a mortgage in early 2026, consolidating your small money owed proper earlier than you apply might end in the next rate of interest on your house.

5. Falling into the “Double Debt” Entice

Consolidating debt hurts your credit score most severely when it results in extra spending. That is the “Double Debt” entice: you progress $10,000 in bank card debt to a private mortgage, leaving your bank cards with a $0 steadiness. For those who haven’t mounted the underlying spending habits, it’s extremely tempting to make use of these “empty” playing cards once more. Inside six months, you may find yourself with a $10,000 mortgage and $10,000 in new bank card debt. This doubles your complete debt-to-income ratio, which, whereas not a direct rating issue, makes you “unlendable” to most banks.

6. By chance Selecting “Debt Settlement” As a substitute

Many predatory corporations in 2026 disguise debt settlement as “debt consolidation.” There’s a large distinction. True consolidation entails paying your money owed in full with a brand new mortgage. Debt settlement entails stopping funds to your collectors so the corporate can “negotiate” a decrease payoff. As Debt.org explains, debt settlement is extraordinarily detrimental to your credit score rating, as each account might be reported as “Settled for Much less Than Agreed,” a mark that stays in your report for seven years and may drop your rating by over 100 factors.

Tips on how to Consolidate Safely

To make sure your consolidation is a win, prioritize “Gentle Pull” pre-qualifications to guard your rating whereas procuring. As soon as the mortgage is lively, arrange autopay instantly; since cost historical past is 35% of your rating, a single missed cost on a brand new consolidation mortgage will undo all of your onerous work. Lastly, deal with your newly “empty” bank cards as emergency-only instruments. Consolidation is a software for restructuring, not a license for a life-style improve.

Have you ever ever seen your credit score rating drop after taking out a consolidation mortgage, and did you discover that protecting your outdated playing cards open helped it bounce again sooner? Go away a remark under and share your expertise with our neighborhood.

You Could Additionally Like…

• How Veterans Can Qualify for Debt Consolidation Loans Regardless of Dangerous Credit score
• 7 Kinds of Folks That Debt Consolidation Packages Work For
• Bank card refinancing vs. debt consolidation: what do that you must know?
• 7 Debt-Consolidation Errors That Wreck Good Credit score
• Credit score Card Debt Is Quietly Crushing Retirees—And It’s Getting Worse Each Month